Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Motels in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| Kenny'S Tipperary Inn |
8.3 / 10 (620 Reviews) |
From 99$ | |
| Carrier Motor Lodge |
7.9 / 10 (293 Reviews) |
From 70$ | |
| Cheshire Welcome Inn |
7.6 / 10 (472 Reviews) |
From 85$ | |
| Clinton Motel |
8.4 / 10 (246 Reviews) |
From 102$ | |
| Aqualina Inn Montauk (Adults Only) |
9.0 / 10 (281 Reviews) |
From 285$ |
Best Motels in Shelter Island
View all photos
Kenny'S Tipperary Inn
From 99$
View all photos
Carrier Motor Lodge
From 70$
View all photos
Cheshire Welcome Inn
From 85$
Cheap Motels in Shelter Island
View all photos
Clinton Motel
From 102$
View all photos
Aqualina Inn Montauk (Adults Only)
From 285$
Hotels in Shelter Island
| Top Service Hotel 🛁 | Kenny'S Tipperary Inn |
| Best Price Hotel 🤑 | Carrier Motor Lodge |
| Family Hotel 👪 | Cheshire Welcome Inn |
View all photos
Montauk Oceanside Suites
From 116$
Motels in Downtown Shelter Island
View all photos
Red Roof Inn Milford - New Haven
From 71$
View all photos
Liberty Inn Old Saybrook
From 144$
View all photos
Southold Beach Motel
From 250$
Shelter Island Extended Stay Motels
View all photos
Budget Host East End Riverhead
From 98$
View all photos
Tower Inn And Suites Of Guilford / Madison
From 65$
View all photos
White Sands Motel
From 209$
Weekly Motels in Shelter Island
View all photos
Windsor Motel
From 55$
View all photos
Red Roof Inn Meriden - Ct
From 70$
View all photos
Shorewood Inn
From 108$
Hourly Motels in Shelter Island
View all photos
Best Way Inn
From 70$
View all photos
Passport Inn And Suites - Middletown
From 76$